Welcome to Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, located at 4165 Buffalo Rd, Rochester, NY, is a culinary gem that offers an authentic Italian experience. Known for its crispy Mama Tony's pizza and delectable calamari, this establishment prides itself on outstanding customer service. Patrons consistently praise the courteous and professional staff, creating a welcoming atmosphere that enhances each dining experience. With enticing daily deals and a commitment to quality — especially noted in their gluten-free offerings — Salvatore’s ensures that every customer leaves satisfied. Overall, it stands as a must-visit destination for pizza lovers in the Rochester area, promising delicious meals and great value.
-
4165 Buffalo Rd, Rochester, NY 14624, United States Hotline: +1 585-594-5555
Welcome to Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, a gem nestled in Rochester, NY, at 4165 Buffalo Rd. This restaurant has established itself as a staple in the community, serving up delicious Italian fare with a focus on high-quality ingredients and exceptional service.
One of the standout features of Salvatore's is its enticing daily deals, which offer incredible value to diners, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a satisfying meal without breaking the bank. As customer Michael “Mike” Brown pointed out, these deals are hard to resist!
But the charm of Salvatore's goes beyond just the pricing. The menu is robust, featuring not only classic pizzas but also delightful appetizers like calamari, which has received rave reviews for its taste and preparation. Carol Vannorman's experience reflects the restaurant's commitment to cleanliness and friendliness, thanks to a dedicated staff that makes every guest feel welcomed.
The service at Salvatore's has garnered admiration as well. Customers like Frank 4 Eternity and Dominic Morsch have praised the professionalism, attentiveness, and positive attitude of their servers, including a standout young gentleman named Anthony. His dedication to ensuring orders are taken with care and food is prepared swiftly exemplifies the restaurant's commitment to a quality dining experience.
For pizza enthusiasts, the Mama Tony's pizza, likened to a “garbage plate pizza,” has emerged as a favorite among locals. Alex noted the unmatched crispiness of the fries at this location, and with each mention, it becomes clear that patrons rave about the golden perfection and flavor of the dishes.
Salvatore's also prioritizes accommodating dietary needs, as reflected in Amanda Brennan’s experience with gluten-free options. The staff's willingness to answer queries and ensure safe dining for allergy-sensitive guests showcases their dedication to guest satisfaction.
In an age where dining experiences can often be hit or miss, Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria stands as a beacon of consistency and quality in Rochester. With an inviting atmosphere, a menu that delights, and a staff that treats you like family, it’s no wonder why locals frequently return to this beloved pizzeria.
So, whether you’re in the mood for a classic pepperoni slice, some perfectly fried calamari, or a unique specialty pizza, make your way to Salvatore's. It's not just a meal; it's an experience worth savoring.
The 10 daily deals are a great value.
Calamari and pizza, yum. Very clean and friendly staff
I just want to say thank you so much to Mike aka Mush aka Portabella and Pat and Montana and Tabitha for being the most courteous and enjoyable and Professional staff that I have ever been happy enough to be served by. They not only made me feel like a super star but cooked food to perfection. THANK YOU GUYS FOR THE BEST EXPERIENCE AND PIZZA IN DA ROC!!!!
This is my go to spot for pizza in Rochester. They do such a great job with their Mama Tony's pizza which is basically a garbage plate pizza. I have been to other locations but the fries at this location are so much more crispy and just perfect. Great work guys!
Wow, I must say. That was the greatest service i’ve ever had. There was a young gentleman by the name Anthony who had the best attitude, most integrity and had a great passion for his job. He took great pride taking my order and making my food as fast as he could. I ordered a large pepperoni and a side of calamari, Let me tell you, both were delicious and very tasteful. The calamari though, unbelievable, absolute 10/10. The pizza was cooked to perfection and the kids loved it. I would very much recommend this place to anyone and i’ll be sure to come back again. I hope to see Anthony again!
Excellent treatment from everyone who works there and especially the manager IAMEN Almonem, he always tries to give the best possible. recommended
We have been here many times with great experiences, today was particularly nice though. With a new celiac diagnosis in our house I was very nervous ordering the gluten free pizza and I believe called back three times with questions and requests. I wish I had the young lady’s name who was so helpful and kind. The pizza came out great and there were no reactions for the allergic family member. They said it was the best pizza they ever had! (6 year old- so take that for what it’s worth) we got subs and they were delicious.
We have only ever had one dish at the Main St Scottsville location that has been wrong. When it was brought to our servers' attention, we were comped for the meal and offered something different if we chose to have that. There's only one server that we refuse to have, and it's because of her attitude. The rest of the staff are awesome, and we recommend this place all the time.